Silence is the Gospel
Last week I read a brief excerpt that talked about a short term evangelism group that had gone out to South America. After a few weeks there, they came back with news for their supporters that over 900 people had made a decision for the gospel while they were there. My first reaction is – WOW! My second reaction is – wait a minute, are we sure?? And my third of course is to feel not enough, to wish that I had numbers to speak of, however I may be skeptical of them when spoken by others.
Reading Frederick Beuchner’s ” Telling the Truth: the Gospel as tragedy, comedy and fairy tale” has been a reminding. The Gospel is good news, it is the good news of a fairy tale. But before the gospel can be a fairy tale, it is first tragedy and comedy. He talks about the moment of silence, when the preacher comes up to the pulpit and the congregation awaits his words. In that moment, he says, the stones cry out. There are no answers, only questions, the silence speaks Gospel in tragedy. And this is what he says of, or to, the preacher . . . And to us:
“Let him tell them the truth. Before the Gospel is a word, it is silence. It is the silence of their own lives and of his life. It is life with the sound turned off so that for a moment or two you can experience it not in terms of the words you make it bearable by but for the unutterable mystery that it it. Let him say, ‘ be silent and know that I am God, says the Lord’. Be silent and know that even by my silence and absence I am known Be silent and listen to the stones cry out.. . . . . Out of the silence let the only real news come, which is sad news before it is glad news and that is fairy tale last of all. . . . . None of us is very good at silence so let us also use words. But words which do not only try to give answers to the questions which we ask or ought to ask but which help us to hear the questions that we do not have words for asking and to hear the silence that those questions rise out of and the silence that is the answer to those questions. Drawing on nothing fancier than the poetry of life, let (us) use words and images that help make the surface of our lives transparent to the truth that lies deep within them, which is the wordless truth of who we are and who God is the Gospel of our meeting.”
I am struck by the thought that mercy ministry, holistic ministry is a way of speaking silence as Gospel. We don’t come first with good news, though perhaps many think we should and sometimes indeed we feel led to do so. We come first in the tragedy where the stones cry out amidst the voices of suffering. I awoke this morning to loud wailing from beyond our walls. The sound of death alluded to after the final plague – a mother mourning. The wailing was loud in the silence of the night, and louder still our questions and the God who alone can answer them. Someone has died and the Gospel is also hidden there, in death, in wailing, in hopeless mourning where no answers are spoken. To live in the third world doing mercy ministry is to acknowledge that we believe in a God who we have not pinned down and who does not always respond as we wish He would. As Jesus wept in the garden after the death of Lazarus, not just the tears of a friend but the tears of “why God.” God is big enough, strong enough, so WHY?
Buechner goes on to say ” . . .to be relevant to the staggering problems of history is to risk being irrelevant to the staggering problems of the ones who sit listening out of their own histories. To deal with the problems to which there is a possible solution can be a way of avoiding the problems to which humanly speaking there is no solution.”
Perhaps mercy ministry can also be too many words spoken into silence. An avoidance to face the bigger problems as we focus on those most fixable. But one day in the pediatric ward and one week spent with students and one night in the home of a mother with AIDs will tell you that for even these things which we have training and experience to face, we feel mostly impotent.
Silence is the Gospel. The silence of sitting beside the body of the dead child and beside the mother whose tears have been cried out. No ” Jesus loves you” can suffice here. The silence of acknowledging rape or incest in the life of a young girl, which no words of hope can erase. The silence of giving the death sentence which is HIV to a strong young man or to his small child. We do bring good news, a veritable fairy tale where the weak are made strong and the maimed made whole; yet first there is the sadness of the why and the silence of questions. I suspect there are many here for whom that silence has spoken poignant truths. I suspect women, dying alone, in the suffering of end-stage, have remembered Pat’s silence, her tears. And in their own silence, believed.



